Tuesday, December 11, 2012

Let's Talk Materialism, with Virginia Woolf and Henry David Thoreau


Materialism is a curse that seems to have affected all aspects of our society. While having things is not inherently a bad thing, our culture seems to have taken it to a whole new level. In many ways, our status among others is determined by how much stuff we have, or by what stuff we have. Materialism is not by any means a new concept. Religious texts, such as the Bible and the Quran wrote about it thousands of years ago, and even warned against it. Several of the texts that we read this semester in Honors 1 talked about materialism quite extensively. For this presentation, I'll be discussing differing opinions on materialism in Virginia Woolf's A Room of One's Own, and Henry David Thoreau's Walden: Or Life in the Woods. Of course, this presentation wouldn't be complete without having a really good visual right? So, to illustrate the viewpoints of Woolf and Thoreau, I've brought along a copy of People magazine. I'll be explaining how each author would react to reading this magazine. First I'll start off with Virginia Woolf. Woolf would love a magazine like this. One of the main themes of her writings in A Room of One's Own is that in order for a woman to write, one of the things she must have is money. Woolf was herself an upper class woman, taken care of by a fortune that was left to her by her aunt. Her emphasis on materialism is prevalent throughout the book, and one cannot doubt that she would enjoy reading about all of these famous women who have money. She may disapprove of the lack of literary quality within the magazine, but I still think that she would enjoy reading about how much times have changed. Henry David Thoreau, on the other hand, would likely throw this magazine on the ground in disgust. Thoreau's book, Walden, is all about his venture out into the woods in order to escape the binding materialism of the world around him. He states that one does not need all these possessions in order to live a fulfilling life. In fact, Thoreau argues that having possessions gets in the way of one's spiritual focus. One can only find the true meaning of life by going out into nature and experiencing it. Seeing this magazine with its overabundance of advertisements, pictures of famous people, and strong emphasis on material goods would probably make him disgusted. Of course, materialism still exists today strongly in our culture. It's estimated that an average person living in a city will see up to 5,000 advertisements a day, whether we realize it or not. In fact, what better time to talk about this topic than around Christmas! But I know, and I include myself in this statement, that in the United States we love our stuff. I realize that not much is going to change. Still, it's good to keep the lessons of those who came before us in mind.

No comments:

Post a Comment